Built the throwaway prototype and sorb tested it: keyboard gone, voice natural,
at 35 percent rather than the 100 percent the spec assumed as default. That
settles the control question — the package exposes setSuppressionLevel and the
wasm carries atten_lim, so DeepFilterNet limits attenuation natively and the
spec's dry/wet mix drops out entirely, taking its missing delay node and phase
problem with it.
Measured what the spec had guessed: 23.27 MB per client, an order of magnitude
above RNNoise. Also found that the package fetches model and wasm from a
third-party CDN at call time, which a self-hosted platform cannot accept — the
asset URL is configurable and the prototype already serves them locally, so that
path is proven rather than assumed.
Still open and decision-relevant: CPU figures, the phone, and the standing cost of
carrying this through every upstream rebase.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
ADR-0006 (Docusaurus as the shared reading surface) is superseded by ADR-0014,
which ADR-0014 had only recorded for ADR-0007. The schema has no 'deprecated', so
superseded with a pointer is the fitting lifecycle state, same shape as ADR-0007.
#0054 evaluates an external architecture spec for filtering keyboard noise with a
WebAssembly model in the client. It holds up on diagnosis, placement and the
awkward parts (128-vs-480 sample buffering, the Chromium worklet leak, SIMD), and
it does not contradict the fork's earlier rejection of ML denoising — that one was
about the server side, for a reason that does not apply here.
It does not hold up on: a missing delay node, which would make the dry/wet mix comb
filter audibly; the premise behind dry/wet at all, since DeepFilterNet can limit
attenuation natively and mixing raw signal back in returns the very keystrokes we
want gone; PESQ figures compared across different test sets; unmeasured bundle size;
throwaway npm packages; and no mention of the standing cost of carrying this through
every upstream rebase.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Thore CimbalandClaude Opus 4.8