Thore Cimbal
eaa00f0ed2
Twelve drift findings and four works-well findings, each citing file paths, line numbers, commit hashes or rows in analysis/data/. Every 'neckbeard mechanism' field names a concrete rule in neckbeard v0.1.1 or states explicitly that none exists.
2.0 KiB
F-003: Five author identities of one person remain, one with a malformed e-mail
category: claim-vs-reality confidence: high
evidence:
shared/commit-zuordnung-2026-08-07.md:19-22states that the rewrite unified author identity: "bei einigen Commits zusätzlich die Autoren-Identität (drei Varianten derselben Person auf eine vereinheitlicht)".- Author fields still present across the six repos
(
analysis/data/timestamp_anonymisation.tsv, columnauthor):Thore Cimbal <cfx@riot.8shield.net>,Scrublord MacBad <Scrublord@Mac.Bad>,ScrublordMcBad <gamemaster@axion1337.de>,sorb <gamemaster@axion1337.de>,sorB <cfxqriot.8shield.net>. - That is five variants, not the three the document says were collapsed into one.
sorB <cfxqriot.8shield.net>(2 commits onThreadNet-Webmain) is not a valid e-mail address — the@is missing,cfx@riotbecamecfxqriot.- The unification reached only the rewritten commits:
managementmain shows a single identity, whileaxion1337.chat-gitopsmain still carries 135 commits asScrublord MacBad <Scrublord@Mac.Bad>and 10 asScrublordMcBad.
impact: Same exposure class as F-002 and the same false sense of completion. In addition,
the malformed address makes those two commits unattributable by tooling that matches on
e-mail, and Scrublord@Mac.Bad leaks a machine name. Contributor statistics on the public
Gitea mirror show one person as four or five contributors.
root-cause pattern: Rule declared repo-wide, applied to a subset — the same pattern as F-002, in the same operation. Both were verified for the property that was easy to check (SHA pairs matched) and not for the property the operation existed to achieve.
neckbeard mechanism: Gap in neckbeard, as in F-002 — no commit or identity hygiene
exists in the framework. The closest structural analogue is scripts/validate.py, which
enforces that declared metadata matches reality for documents (check_fields,
apply_rules); nothing does the equivalent for commit metadata.